You don’t need a verdict on whether you’re a “real writer.” You need to know where the draft stops working and what to change next. A long scene, a blunt line or a quiet opening can all work. The problem is what the reader loses along the way.
Use these five checks on one troublesome sequence first. Fixing a scene’s purpose may save you from polishing dialogue you’ll end up cutting.
A five-minute self-check
- Opening: What makes this moment worth watching?
- Dialogue: What does each speaker want from the other?
- Structure: What changes because this scene happens?
- Action: Can the reader follow the behavior, space and important details?
- Premise: Can you explain the central situation without reciting the plot?
1. The opening delays the interesting part
A script can begin with a conversation, a routine or a striking image. Give the reader something specific to notice: an imbalance, a desire, an unanswered question, a revealing choice.
Invented example: Someone wakes, brushes their teeth and leaves for work. That might be disposable setup. But if they’re rehearsing an apology while avoiding a second toothbrush, the routine has a question inside it. Keep the detail if the story follows through on that interest.
The alternative—someone sprinting out late in mismatched shoes—creates activity. It still needs a reason to matter. Speed and tension aren’t the same thing.
Revision: Mark the first moment that makes you curious. Try beginning there, then restore the earlier material needed to understand it. If the quieter opening is better, keep it. Use our first-page checklist to test what the reader actually learns.
2. The dialogue explains a situation without changing it
People sometimes say exactly what they mean. They also explain things. The question is whether the exchange belongs to these people, at this moment, or exists mainly to brief the audience.
Compare these invented lines:
“As you know, I’m upset because you stole my inheritance and left me with nothing.”
“It wasn’t enough to take the house, was it? You had to take everything else too.”
The second is less like a summary, but it still needs a listener with something to do. Add an answer that changes the encounter: a denial, an offer, a demand for proof. Both people should have a part in shaping the exchange.
In the opening of Aaron Sorkin’s The Social Network screenplay, Mark and Erica repeatedly talk past each other. His concern with status and her reactions emerge through the exchange. Study the interruptions and misunderstandings; copying the surface speed won’t recreate the relationship.
Revision: Beside each speaker, write an intention: persuade, reassure, avoid, challenge, recruit. Read the scene aloud. Where does a reply force the other person to change tactics? If nobody reacts, try the exercises in our dialogue guide.
3. The middle repeats pressure without changing the problem
A series of arguments can look busy while leaving the story in the same place. Check the consequences: a promise made, an ally lost, a fact learned, a route closed off. Emotional changes count too, provided the audience can understand them.
Invented example: A tenant asks a landlord for repairs. The landlord refuses. The tenant asks again, more angrily. Instead, the tenant could recruit the neighbors, then discover one has privately accepted a deal. Now the next scene has a different problem.
Try swapping two scenes as a diagnostic. If nothing changes, investigate what each contributes. A nonlinear story isn’t automatically broken: a sequence can build meaning through contrast, repetition or withheld information. Make that pattern intentional.
Revision: Summarize each scene, then add “afterward…” and its consequence. For a sagging stretch, choose a decision or discovery that changes the available choices. A midpoint label won’t create that change for you.
4. The action is hard to picture—or cluttered with decoration
Action writing guides attention. It tells us what happens, where to look and what matters. Cutting it until nothing remains is no more helpful than describing every object.
Invented setting example: “The room was filled with antique furniture, the kind you’d expect in a Victorian mansion, and the smell of lavender lingered in the air.” A more focused version might be: “A Victorian sitting room. Faded upholstery. A candle burns beside an unopened letter.” The letter gives us something to notice, if it matters later. A candle’s appearance alone cannot tell an audience it smells of lavender.
Invented behavior example: “John is nervous about the meeting” gives a broad intention. “John straightens his tie. Checks the door. Straightens it again” gives observable behavior. Context still matters: those actions could suggest several feelings. Choose behavior that belongs to John rather than piling on generic nervous gestures.
In Scriptnotes 521, John August and Craig Mazin discuss action density and reading rhythm. Short blocks can help, but they also identify a sample where too many action interruptions break the dialogue’s flow. There is no two-to-four-line allowance for an entire scene.
Up‘s married-life montage uses images and music together. It is wordless, not silent. Composer Michael Giacchino explains how Ellie’s theme carries her presence into Carl’s later story. Dialogue, sound and visuals can each do important work.
Revision: Break an overloaded passage at changes of action or attention. Remove details the scene doesn’t use. Keep the information needed to follow it, and leave a strong conversation room to breathe.
5. The premise is buried under plot explanation
A clear premise and a high-concept premise aren’t the same thing. An intimate drama can have a precise central conflict without a spectacular hook. Theme is another question: the ideas and tensions the story explores through its choices.
Invented example: “It’s about family, forgiveness, money and three generations” names subjects. “A daughter must persuade her estranged father to sell the failing family restaurant before its debts swallow her savings” gives us a person, a task and resistance. The story could explore loyalty, pride or obligation; that sentence doesn’t need to announce its message.
Revision: Draft a logline, then compare it with the pages. If they describe different stories, decide which one you want to develop. Look for choices that put the underlying tension under pressure, rather than making every scene repeat a moral.
Before you send the PDF
Do a formatting and proofreading pass after the substantial revisions. Use your software’s scene heading, action, character, dialogue and parenthetical elements rather than arranging the page with spaces. Check the exported PDF as well as the editor.
A parenthetical that changes how a line is delivered goes before the affected speech, not underneath it as a trailing label. This invented example shows element order; its web spacing is not a margins template:
JANE
(to the empty room)
Well, that's just great.
Keep the direction when it clarifies the moment. Remove it when the surrounding action already does the job. The Academy’s annotated format sample demonstrates placement; our format cheatsheet covers the main elements. Check the recipient’s current submission instructions.
Confirm the PDF opens, character names are consistent and you’re sending the requested material. Keep a dated copy. Formatting makes the draft easier to read; it cannot guarantee a sale or explain every rejection.
For prose-specific opening problems, Derek’s first-chapter red flags offer a related check. For this script, finish one revision pass and read the changed sequence again. Is the original problem clearer? That’s a useful stopping point for today.






